Most buy-to-let landlords are making money, according to research from ModaMortgages reported by Mortgage Strategy. The finding cuts against a prevailing narrative in the UK property press of a rental sector in retreat, squeezed by higher mortgage rates, tighter regulation and rising taxation. Instead, ModaMortgages suggests that the core economics of letting residential property in Britain remain sound for the majority of landlords currently operating in the market.

This matters because the buy-to-let sector has absorbed years of policy headwinds that many commentators predicted would make the model unworkable. The phased withdrawal of mortgage interest relief, the additional stamp duty surcharge on second homes, tighter lending criteria introduced by the Prudential Regulation Authority and the looming reform of the private rented sector have all been cited as reasons landlords might exit en masse. If ModaMortgages is right that most are still profitable, it implies the sector has adapted rather than collapsed, and that predictions of a landlord exodus have been overstated relative to the lived experience of those still active in the market.

The implications differ sharply by region. In high-value markets such as London and Surrey, where capital values are elevated and yields have historically been thinner, landlords have had less room to absorb higher borrowing costs, and profitability there is likely to be more marginal than in the cities where ModaMortgages' research points to a healthier picture overall. By contrast, cities such as Manchester, Birmingham, Leeds, Liverpool and Newcastle have long offered stronger rental yields relative to purchase price, giving landlords in these markets a bigger buffer against rate rises and cost inflation. Investors weighing where to deploy capital over the next year should treat this regional disparity as a central factor, rather than assuming the ModaMortgages findings apply uniformly across the country.

For existing landlords, the research offers a degree of reassurance that the fundamentals of the asset class have not broken down, even if margins have tightened. For first-time buyers and prospective tenants, however, a buy-to-let sector that remains broadly profitable is not necessarily good news. If landlords continue to find letting worthwhile despite higher costs, there is less pressure on the sector to shrink supply, which could help stabilise rents in some markets, but it also means competition for stock between landlords and owner-occupiers is unlikely to ease quickly, particularly in the cities named above where demand continues to outstrip the availability of family housing.

Commercial investors and developers should read the ModaMortgages findings as a signal that residential letting remains an attractive asset class relative to some commercial segments, where occupier demand has been more volatile. This may encourage continued institutional interest in build-to-rent schemes, particularly in regional cities where yields are more favourable, reinforcing a trend that has already seen significant capital flow into purpose-built rental developments outside London over recent years.

Looking ahead to the next six to twelve months, the ModaMortgages research suggests the buy-to-let sector is entering a period of relative stability rather than further contraction. Landlords who have survived the recent tightening of mortgage affordability tests and tax changes appear to have adjusted their portfolios, pricing and financing structures to remain viable. Barring a fresh shock, such as a sharp rise in interest rates or further adverse tax policy from the Treasury, the sector looks set to continue functioning broadly as it has, with profitability intact for most participants even as the operating environment remains more demanding than in the pre-2016 era.

The clear takeaway for the market is that reports of buy-to-let's demise have been premature. ModaMortgages' findings indicate a sector that has absorbed significant regulatory and fiscal pressure without losing its core profitability, a resilience that should inform how landlords, lenders and policymakers think about the private rented sector's trajectory over the coming year.

Key Takeaways

  • ModaMortgages research reported by Mortgage Strategy found most buy-to-let landlords are currently profitable, challenging narratives of sector decline.
  • Regional variation matters: higher-yield cities such as Manchester, Birmingham, Leeds, Liverpool and Newcastle are likely better placed than high-value markets like London and Surrey to sustain landlord profitability.
  • Continued landlord profitability may limit the easing of supply competition between landlords and first-time buyers in high-demand regional markets.
  • Commercial and institutional investors may see the findings as reinforcing the case for continued investment in build-to-rent schemes outside London.